Home Dental Care Activated Charcoal Toothpaste: Is It Healthy?

Activated Charcoal Toothpaste: Is It Healthy?

by Josephine Andrews
Published: Last Updated on 190 views

Natural products are in demand – be it soap nuts for washing or lava as a shampoo. In the field of tooth cleaning, the latest trend is toothpaste with activated charcoal. Teeth are said to be whiter with the black pasta – without bleaching or emery substances. The cleaning performance should correspond to that of conventional toothpastes. But what good is the charcoal in toothpaste? Read everything you need to know about toothpaste with activated charcoal here.

Is activated charcoal toothpaste healthy?

What exactly is in the charcoal toothpaste has not yet been tested by independent bodies. There are currently no scientific studies that can make an objective statement about the benefits and risks of black toothpaste . Diverse expert opinions are also missing.

On the other hand, more is known about the activated carbon used. It is produced on an industrial scale by combustion and activation processes. So it doesn’t come directly from nature.

For example, a commonly used type of activated charcoal in black toothpaste is carbon black. The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies carbon black as possibly carcinogenic to humans. To what extent this applies to the amounts used in black toothpaste remains to be investigated.

Dangerous polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons can also be produced during the production of activated carbon. So that these do not end up in black toothpaste, manufacturers should clean the charcoal. As a consumer, you could ask the manufacturer directly whether this is done.

Another important question is: does the activated charcoal in black toothpaste scrub dirt off teeth as reliably as regular toothpaste?

Alternative toothpaste

In addition to the classic toothpaste, there are also more natural variants. Those who would like to do without chemical ingredients such as flavors or preservatives can choose from various products: herbal toothpastes or tooth gels made from marigold blossoms, for example. Pure white chalk is also a popular alternative to brushing your teeth.

Such alternative ingredients in toothpaste serve the natural trend and are very popular. Now even activated carbon comes out of the tube. Whether in soap, face cream or shower gel: Activated charcoal seems to be the new miracle cure in cosmetics. Some people even stir it into their smoothie. Black toothpaste always provides an element of surprise because, like most activated charcoal products, it is actually pitch black.

Toothpaste with activated charcoal: how it works!

But is the activated charcoal actually effective for cleaning teeth? The following has been proven: Due to its special pore structure with an extremely high surface area of ​​up to 1,500 m 2 /g, activated carbon is a strong binding agent. Think of the principle as a sponge that traps substances in its pores .

Activated carbon has been established in water and air filtration for decades. Activated charcoal is also used in medicine as a general antidote. Doctors administer activated charcoal (except for corrosive substances) in accidents involving swallowed chemicals. It also removes microbes and their toxins from the intestines in diarrhea. A kilogram costs just two euros, and best of all: you cannot overdose on activated carbon.

If the charcoal soaks up dirt in so many areas, then it can be just as useful in black toothpaste, right? In fact, a type of black toothpaste has actually been in use for a long time. Before there was toothpaste, people cleaned their teeth with ashes from wood burning or tobacco. In Africa and Asia people still brush their teeth with ash and charcoal.

In toothpaste, activated charcoal is rather inactive

Prof. Dr. Carolina Ganß, President of the German Society for Preventive Dentistry. She explained in the consumer magazine ÖKO-TEST (2016) that the reactive activated charcoal was probably already fully loaded with the other ingredients in the black toothpaste before it could even have an effect on the teeth. In general, activated charcoal itself is harmless to teeth and gums , the expert continues.

Scouring effect removes discolouration

It is best to try it out for yourself to see whether you actually get white teeth with activated charcoal. Use black toothpaste just like your previous toothpaste. You can use it to remove stains and leftover food from your teeth. However, experts suspect that the black toothpaste’s mechanism of action is primarily due to the abrasiveness of the carbon particles. Silicate compounds in classic toothpaste, for example, also have such a polishing effect.

How well does black toothpaste clean?

Cleaning particles are the emery material of a toothpaste and can account for up to 60 percent of the ingredients. They support the abrasion of plaque and leftover food with the toothbrush , but must not damage the tooth substance. This is known for sure about calcium carbonate (main component of whiting ) and silicon dioxide. These compounds are therefore ingredients in many toothpastes. How well the black toothpaste scrubs cannot yet be said in general terms.

Fluoride should be included

Not only the scouring power, but also the fluoride content in the toothpaste is important. Whether white or black toothpaste: use products with fluoride levels of 1,450 to 1,500 ppm (parts per million). This deprives the caries bacteria in your mouth of the breeding ground and hardens your tooth enamel. Tooth decay, inflammation of the gums and periodontium then occur less frequently.

If you are fundamentally curious about new effective substances for your dental care, you could try xylitol, for example. This is a natural sugar alcohol that has been shown to reduce tooth decay and is just as sweet but significantly lower in calories than table sugar.

You may also like

Leave a Comment